Another Twin Tale Of Two Buyers
This morning, I listed a barely used horse saddle for sale on Ebay. New, this saddle and accessories cost more than $400. I started the listing at $160 and also implemented the Buy-It-Now option for $250. A bargain, no question about it.
Within an hour, I had an email from a buyer who wanted me to end the auction early so that she could buy the saddle for $200 - and moments later, another buyer used the Buy-It-Now option to complete the purchase.
The first buyer could have placed a bid for $160 to start… but she knew that the bidding would go much higher than that. Instead, she figured she could offer me $200 to end the auction early - and she would "steal" the saddle.
The second buyer - recognizing an outstanding value - jumped on the Buy-It-Now. She knew that $250 was a good deal - and my 100% feedback gave her the assurance she needed.
This isn’t the first time I have seen this behavior on Ebay. While one buyer is trying to "steal" an auction - another comes along and makes the purchase. The exact thing happened a few months ago while I was selling a camera lens. While one buyer was telling me that $600 was a good offer - another was making the purchase for $900.
The same principles apply to buying real estate.
Last month, I worked with two different buyers who placed offers on seperate foreclosed properties. In the first case, I showed the first client a home back in late November when the home was priced at $150K. When asked how much the home was worth, I told my client that it was worth $130K - and that we should wait until the price is reduced, as the seller will not want to take that big of discount off of list price.
Why? Because instead of dropping $20K, the seller will test the market at $10K less before accepting $20K less.
We waited through several price drops until the property was listed at OUR price. Then we asked for a generous contribution from the seller towards the buyer’s closing costs.
My other buyer wanted a home that was priced at $175K, but was worth $155K. The seller dropped the price to $145K in the hope of getting multiple offers - which they did receive. Our offer was the strongest - and the seller countered us, offering to meet us halfway on closing costs. Instead of countering back - my client decided to stand pat on her offer. Take it or leave it.
Although the seller’s counteroffer still priced the property below market - my client did not care. She thought they should take our offer with no counter-offer. So, the listing agent will counter one of the other prospective buyers… and someone else will get the home.
This isn’t the first time I have seen this happen. Many people are confused about what they should offer - as well as what they should expect. My advice is to look for value and work from there. When a property is priced right - don’t expect the seller to meet your aggressive offer with an abundance of joy - not even in this market.
As always, if you have any questions regarding real estate in the greater Atlanta area, feel free to contact me here.



By